#28 - Native American Reparations Part 1: What’s The Tab For Genocide?

#28 - Native American Reparations Part 1: What’s The Tab For Genocide?

In this Part 1, we begin to make the case for reparations for Native Americans - a case 500 years in the making. We shine a light on the displacement, colonization, and genocide by a U.S. government hellbent on ever more profits and power. We expose myths and lies we’ve all been fed to camouflage these crimes. What is the tab for destroying entire cultures, nations, and civilizations?

In this Part 1, we begin to make the case for reparations for Native Americans - a case 500 years in the making. We shine a light on the displacement, colonization, and genocide by a U.S. government hellbent on ever more profits and power. We expose myths and lies we’ve all been fed to camouflage these crimes. What is the tab for destroying entire cultures, nations, and civilizations? 


SHOW NOTES


BOOKS ON INDIGENOUS HISTORY AND RESISTANCE

FURTHER READING

  • More on the “Manifest Destiny” myth - here

 

  • More on the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 - here


  • More on the Buffalo Soldiers - here

 
 

HIGHLIGHTS OF EPISODE:

o [4:50] Settler colonization and theft of Indigenous lands by U.S. government

o [7:51] Myth of “Manifest Destiny”

o [10:21] Role of treaties in perpetuating genocide and land theft 

o [11:28] 1868 Ft. Laramie Treaty and U.S. government’s violation

o [14:41] Myth of inevitability of U.S. genocide and land theft

o [21:19] Complex history between Native and Black Americans

o [26:06] Case for Native American reparations

 

Contact Tony & Adam

 

Subscribe

[00:00:00] So I want to give a shout out to my mother, Terry. Mom, thank you for raising me to see the world through an anti-racist lens, to understand the lies of the powers that be, to understand the many evils of capitalism. You taught me to see things that we're all brainwashed not to see.

[00:00:20] Yeah, Adam, you know, it's strange. Your mom always struck me as just being like a step ahead. I don't know how to explain it, you know, but just like forward looking, forward thinking and just, yeah, like I said, kind of a step ahead in terms of her view of the world. Yeah, that's nice to hear. And, you know, she's always been a loyal supporter of this podcast. But she has had one consistent question for us, right?

[00:00:46] Mm-hmm. And so, early on, several years ago, when we were just getting started with our first episodes, she would, I'd ask her what she thought about the last one. She'd say, well, yeah, it was a pretty good episode, but when are you going to talk about Native American reparations? Right. A few years go by and we did our two-part series on Martin Luther King's assassination. And she said, yeah, that was good, but, you know, you guys still haven't had an episode on Native American reparations. Mm-hmm. Yeah. You know, when are you going to do that? And so, you know, Mom, you're right.

[00:01:13] It is high time that we go there and we're going to get to it today. So, Adam, for the record, mothers are always right. Okay. Just ask my mom. Marie will show enough tell you. Yes. Right? We know better than to question. Yeah. Lesson of the podcast. Absolutely. Absolutely.

[00:01:46] Hold out the bill. Don't just have more to destroy. You'll depend on our will. No hands on the will. I don't take control. Oh, no, here we go. Down to grab your hoe. Welcome back to Pay the Tab. We're two lawyers making the case for reparations to black Americans one story at a time. Today we kick off a two-part series on Native American reparations.

[00:02:09] You know, similar to black American history, the story of Native American genocide doesn't fit neatly, you know, within all the myths and propaganda and BS, you know, the U.S. that we've been fed. That's for sure. Right? So as a function of that, as a result, you know, we tend to shy away from it, steer clear, dance around it, or avoid the topic entirely. Yep.

[00:02:33] But in this part one, we're going to start off with some basic history to help ground the conversation and, you know, make sure we're all kind of working with the same general information. Sounds good. Cool. So let's go back, right, and take a long view of, you know, this topic, right?

[00:02:49] So the broad sweep of the last 500 years, you know, horrific rise of colonialism, capitalism, global domination by European powers, all those factors came together. Starting in the early 1500s, right? Right. Put it very plainly, a few European kings embarked on this conquest, murderous conquest and theft of land, just straight out, and human beings.

[00:03:19] The first century alone, the 1500s, was labeled the Great Dying Period, right? Which would give you some hint that it was marked by mass murder, genocide committed by Europeans. In many cases, they brought deadly diseases with them, sometimes by design, right? And the result, over the period of 100 years, just 90% of the people living in the Western Hemisphere were killed. Let that sink in.

[00:03:47] Approximately 60 million folks were reduced to 6 million. That's just insane. The mass deaths were so immense that it actually caused the Earth's temperature to drop, an impact that can still be measured. And that was just the beginning, right? Yes.

[00:04:03] So in the centuries to follow, right, the 1600s through the 1800s, you have these European powers continuing their conquest, their violent, murderous quest for wealth and extraction of resources in the Western Hemisphere. Right. We see multiple genocides of the people who were already living there, many, many different civilizations and tribes and nations of people throughout the Western Hemisphere. Yep.

[00:04:30] And, of course, part of this whole criminal project, as we already have discussed, is the mass kidnapping and enslavement of people from Africa. Yes. And the transatlantic slave trade and all that came after that. But during this period, we really see, like you said, the birth of this modern system of colonization, of capitalism, of empire. And, of course, here in what's now known as the United States, a particularly violent form of settler colonization.

[00:04:59] So to put the American genocide in perspective, just in the 1800s alone, right, that one century, the United States government stole almost 2 billion acres of land from Native American people. A million. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So we're talking, you know, the majority of the whole country in such a short period of time.

[00:05:25] And, you know, many dozens and hundreds of indigenous nations and tribes from coast to coast were forced off their land, killed, and forced into smaller and smaller areas that today are known as reservations. These tiny little dots on the map in the land, you know, the worst land in the country.

[00:05:48] Meanwhile, as we know, the U.S. government gave a huge portion of this stolen land to the white so-called settlers, either for free or for extremely cheap in what were known as land grants. Yes. A lot of that was in the 1800s, you know, not very long ago. And as we've said before, you know, a huge portion of white Americans' wealth today, like the white families today in America. Right.

[00:06:16] A huge portion of that family wealth traces back to that massive theft and redistribution of stolen lands in the land grants. Yeah, which makes it absurd when people talk about pulling themselves up by their bootstraps and other people just need to work harder like, you know, my family did. No, your family got handed some stolen property. Right. You know? Right. That's always something other people have to do is use the bootstraps. Exactly. Right. So let's, you know, we're two lawyers, right?

[00:06:44] So let's look at the role that the American legal system played in all this. You know, a key part of the genocide and land theft was, you know, rooted in the development of quote unquote laws to help justify them. Right. There's an infamous case from 1823, Johnson versus McIntosh, which unveiled the quote doctrine of discovery, close quote, which it's hard to even get your head around to make it make sense.

[00:07:11] But basically it stated that colonizing powers own the land that they take, that they quote unquote discovered, notwithstanding the fact that there were folks that were actually living there on the land who possessed the land. Native tribes were given a quote right of occupancy. Right. Thank you. Thank you for letting me, you know, like reside on my property that you've now snatched. Right. So let's let that sink in for a moment.

[00:07:38] How in the hell do you discover a place that was already settled and owned and occupied? Right. Right. This is the U.S. Supreme Court's key ruling here on the subject, and they're just making shit up. This whole notion of manifest destiny, right, was key justification that said that, you know, well, initially it was intended to mean that free people could continue to build and grow on their space. Hmm. Right. I didn't know that. Yeah.

[00:08:05] That was the initial meaning of it, but it was used and it was twisted and contorted actually to use as an excuse to conquer and colonize Native Americans and steal their land. And based on Christianity, right? Yeah, absolutely. It's our destiny to basically take over the world because we're Christian. We're ordained to do this. Yes. And this is in the Supreme Court decision. It is. That's a part and parcel of the Supreme Court decision that is still viable law today. And, you know, we studied this in law school. Right. Right.

[00:08:32] It's a, you know, standard property law case. How did this stuff hit you when we were in law school? Do you remember? Insane. It always felt insane. I remember when we were in law school having your property law class, constitutional law class, and, you know, learning about the law and its sort of revered, you know, system of precedent and the courts culminating in the Supreme Court.

[00:08:57] And even at the time, I was like, wait, you know, none of this is based on fairness or justice at all. It all comes down to these kind of right of, like you say, right of discovery by the Christians. And then that sets up property rights. So we respect property rights more than anything in the courts once it's the property of the white people and their corporations. But other than that, no one else has really counted. Yeah. Yeah.

[00:09:26] And I don't remember the case, that case specifically, but I just remember generally there not being a lot of pushback, a lot of discussion. You know, it was just presented as this is the law. That's true. Not a lot of discussion in class. And certainly, yeah, not a lot of provocative professor questions. No. Yeah. Yeah.

[00:09:46] But it was weird, you know, going to law school during that time and learning about how laws evolved in these so-called property rights when it became very clear very early on that the fundamental purpose of those laws was to protect the wealthy. Once the property had been stolen. Right, right. You got to do that first. Well, sure, sure, sure. You have to justify that. Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. But exactly. The whole basis is to protect the stolen property for the thieves. Exactly. And that's our law.

[00:10:16] And so God bless the law. Let's turn to the treaties, which are considered the supreme law of the land, right? The U.S. entered into hundreds of treaties with indigenous tribes and nations. That's right. So the treaties were an essential aspect of committing the genocide. Yeah. Right? It legitimized the land thefts. Right. Puts it down in writing. Put it down in writing. Supported by law.

[00:10:45] It actually bought some measure of peace, if you will, with native folks. Because in return, they were granted, quote unquote, a small portion of the stolen lands. Right. Which is totally absurd. It's like, okay, you stole my land. You're giving me back a little pittance of it. Yeah. And I'm supposed to be cool with that. Not over 200 treaties were entered into, and not a single one of them was fully honored. Or as I understand it, eventually not honored at all, right?

[00:11:12] We eventually violated, ignored, and basically stole the land back. Absolutely. And continued the genocide. And the native people back then and still today were saying, hey, at least stick with your own laws, your own treaties here. You would think, right? By far, the biggest treaty of them all was the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty. We're talking more than 70 million acres of land. Right. It's about the size of the current state of Nevada was covered by this treaty, right? Yes.

[00:11:42] And a lot of this area had been sacred land for multiple indigenous nations. So this treaty was really hugely important for the indigenous peoples of the west part of the continent. But as you said, with all the treaties, the land was just stolen back over time. The U.S. government just violated and ignored the treaty. And especially after someone reported that gold was discovered in the area. And so there was a so-called gold rush there.

[00:12:12] Right. And in what was sovereign indigenous lands, even under the U.S. law. And then adding insult to injury, you know, the crowning jewel for the U.S. government of this land was what is known as Mount Rushmore. This tribute built by an avowed racist, fascist guy about 100 years ago. So and so it's just, you know, the largest of all the travesties with those treaties.

[00:12:38] And interesting footnote in 1980, the case about the basically the theft of the under the Fort Laramie Treaty got to the U.S. Supreme Court. And the U.S. Supreme Court actually awarded the Sioux nations more than 100 million dollars in reparations. Which is amazing in and of itself. Yeah, it's a lot of money, especially back then, you know, maybe not relative to the harm.

[00:13:04] But for the Supreme Court to rule that is interesting for violating the treaty. Right. But the the leaders of the Sioux nations refused to accept the payment. And their quote was, our land is not for sale. You talk about standing on principle. That's that's something. Yeah. Like you said earlier, you know, we are all fed a lifetime worth of myths and brainwashing about Native people in America. Yes. Right.

[00:13:30] You know, the truth and the magnitude of the genocide is just it's too much for us to process. And we almost have to look look away and not go there. Yeah. Yeah. I don't even know if I would say it's it's too much for us to process. I think it's just that there's not a collective will to want to go there. Well, that's a really good point. You know? Yeah. Yeah. We can process a lot of things. Yeah. We process all kinds of horrors. You know, this is one that we've chosen not not to. That's a good point. Yeah. And, you know, a lot of this, of course, is by design from the powers that be.

[00:14:01] And to help us to look away. We really have all been brainwashed by, you know, the ruling powers of our country, our government, our media. We starting when we're little kids. Right. Totally. Totally. I mean, starting with the fairy tales were told about the so-called settlers, pilgrims, the early colonizers, you know, the Thanksgiving holiday. All that. On and on. Yeah. Yeah.

[00:14:24] In popular culture, you know, the TV, the quote-unquote, you know, Western genre and what that depicts and what it doesn't depict. I mean, I never understood the whole thing about Westerns. Like, it's this big thing among movie buffs still. Sure. And like, I'm sorry. This is what we're talking about? Right. You know, it occurs to me like there's an assumption that's at the heart of all of these myths, either ignoring the human beings who were already living here, getting their land stolen, and ignoring the violence, ignoring the genocide.

[00:14:54] It's almost like there's an assumption that this was all inevitable. You know, that the people with the biggest weapons are just going to take the land. Period. Like, in general. That's just how it goes. That's just how the world works. Right. Yeah. And just get other people off of it. And, yeah, and that never sat right. And I saw a quote from, I think it was somebody in the Chinese government a while back was commenting on the sort of European colonization of the whole hemisphere here.

[00:15:23] And, you know, this guy said, you know, a lot of other nations also had weapons. They had, you know, murderous weapons that when they needed to use them, there were wars. Other nations had science and culture and all that. But what set the Europeans apart was those guys had the ability and the inclination to just wipe out entire populations solely for profit. They had the appetite for it. Right. For sure.

[00:15:50] And it's sort of like, it's almost like the whole world is still just sort of reeling from the shock of like, yeah, you guys are just going to do that. Yeah. And, you know, just to put a finer point on something you mentioned that the similarity with black history is that there hasn't been a break from this indoctrination. Right. You know, it's been a continuous stream. And I think that's also part of how we are kept ignorant. Right.

[00:16:16] By just getting consistently, continually bombarded with this BS propaganda. Right. And no real way to make sense of it unless, you know, you dig deep and you take the time to research and investigate and point out where all the fallacies are. But, you know, who does that? But the government's never acknowledged anything ever. At all. Right. So, you know, under any of our presidents. Yeah. Right. And so if you look at sort of older movies and, you know, some of the writings in the 1700s and 1800s, sometimes it seems shocking.

[00:16:45] Like, wow, people were saying stuff that was this racist just right out in the open and justifying these genocides. But it's like there was never a time when that was renounced. Correct. Our government, there was never any official statement of like, oh, man, this was really horrendous what we did. Right. Forget about reparations. Just acknowledge. Right. Which is a form of reparations in and of itself. Right. Yeah, exactly. Let's just reckon with what really was. Yeah. And is. Yeah, totally.

[00:17:13] And, you know, one of the other myths that's still with us today that was pointed out by Professor Kyle Mays at UCLA, who is an expert in Afro-Indigenous history in the U.S., is the myth of erasure, which basically says that, you know, all the Native people were killed. Right. They were all gone. Sure. And so that's very sad, but there's really nothing to be done, you know, and we need to move on.

[00:17:53] Mm-hmm. Yeah, and it makes it easy to put aside reparations if there's nobody here to receive reparations, right? Right. It's definitely a key piece of our brainwashing to ignore and erase all the stories of Indigenous movements for justice, of pushing back, right, of fighting back. Yep. And those stories, the stories of resistance are for sure buried and not talked about. At all. Right? Yeah.

[00:18:16] Like, you can take, for example, we remember in our young lives the American Indian movement starting in the 70s, AIM, A-I-M. Yeah. Right? Extremely influential and had, you know, members from across the country.

[00:18:34] I remember one of the news stories when we were young, the Wounded Knee standoff where a group, I believe, led by AIM members reoccupied part of those Native lands that the government stole under the Fort Laramie Treaty. Mm-hmm. But, you know, it was a relatively small piece of land where there had been a massacre in the previous century at Wounded Knee.

[00:18:57] And there was a standoff that actually lasted over 70 days, a standoff with the government forces. But in the end, you know, the U.S. government demonized the group, infiltrated them, used violence to where the AIM leaders were either killed or imprisoned, right? And so that's a pattern that we see throughout our history when there is resistance. Right?

[00:19:20] And then more recently, some folks may recall the Dakota Access Pipeline, this 1,000-mile oil pipeline that was built in the western U.S. from, I guess it went from North Dakota down into Illinois. Mm-hmm. And, but in the process, you know, it was, it went through all kinds of Native lands that, areas that are still Native lands, including some sacred places. Mm-hmm.

[00:20:12] Mm-hmm. That are so much growing these days. You know, they shut down the protests, used violence, infiltration, and there was just further desecration of Native lands. Pulled the same old tricks. And this was about 10 years ago, right? Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Exactly. And so, you know, the protests were in the news that fall. And then by early 2017, the oil was flowing. And, you know, they had shut down the protest and moved on.

[00:20:39] We definitely see that at every turn, the U.S. government and its private forces push back hard at every kind of resistance and demonize the resistance fighters. Which is a key aspect, right? Yep. To get, if not public buy-in, at least not public dissent. Exactly. Exactly. So the way the news is portrayed, both in Wounded Knee in the 70s and Standing Rock in the 2010s, was, you know, oh, there's some, you know, violent activists.

[00:21:07] And the bad elements are getting in there. And the radicals. And, you know, that's just by the corporate-controlled media saying that. Well, let's begin the conversation about the relationship between Black American and Native Americans. You know, it's an interesting and somewhat complicated history. Yeah. And we'll dig into it a little more in part two.

[00:21:31] But throughout our country's history, Native Americans and Black Americans have had a somewhat complex relationship of both cooperation on the one hand and confrontation on the other hand. So looking at the 1600s, where enslaved folks from Africa were integrated into our labor system here. Right. Right. Alongside Native Americans.

[00:21:56] This led to some alliances between the groups, right, in revolts against several, you know, colonizers where they were, you know, working on the same team and said, yeah, that's our common opponent, our common oppressor. Let's rise up. Because I guess the colonial powers at that time were still trying to use both populations for basically forced labor. Free labor. Exactly. Free forced labor. Right.

[00:22:22] And so they realized that they had a common interest and a common enemy and used that to rise up. Fast forward to the 19th century where the Black Buffalo soldiers were used to wage violence against indigenous nations. The Buffalo soldiers were an all-Black army, all-Black army troops that were created in 1866.

[00:22:50] And they spent over the course of the next 20 years providing security for white settler convoys. This inevitably led to several battles with Native American tribes. Sure. Right. And these were not two groups that were initially had any beef or had any reason to be fighting, but they were put up to do this. And, you know, just one of many examples of the divide and conquer. Yes. You know, scheme that the U.S. government has perpetrated throughout, you know, the nation's history.

[00:23:19] I mean, the other point which, you know, bears mentioning is the fact that, you know, some Native American tribes actually enslaved African Americans. Right. Right. You know, there were these so-called five civilized tribes of the Southeast, Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw Creek, and Seminole. To what extent, you know, don't know, right? It's unclear.

[00:23:48] So, again, it's tricky because we don't want to overplay that point and feed into the whole divide and conquer schema. But I think it does bear mentioning that there were on both sides, right, both African American folks, you know, messing with Native and Native folks messing with Black folks. Right. As part of this ghastly system that was being imposed on everybody, right, by the colonizing powers. Yes. Yeah.

[00:24:16] I had heard somewhere that, you know, the actual enslavement of Black people by those five tribes was very small. Yeah. Yeah. It was just like a handful of the most wealthy elite members of those societies. But, you know, it's not to—certainly not to downplay it. Right. But it does seem like one of those things that people love to talk about to sort of poo-poo any discussion of reparations for either group. It'd be like, you know, oh, so, you know, Native people did slavery too.

[00:24:46] So, okay. We're all off the hook. Yeah. Yeah. And for that matter, the African rulers in West Africa sold their own people into slavery. Right. So that's the big deal. That justifies, right? Yeah. Right. Yeah. Like you say, it's all about divide and conquer and stuff. Yeah. Yeah. Another point worth mentioning is in the 1960s, right, the Black Power Movement, the Civil Rights Movement were happening. Right.

[00:25:10] That has actually been attributed to helping to aspire the Red Power Movement organization. Yeah. So we've talked about AIM, the American Indian Movement. Many Native activists worked with Martin Luther King on the Poor People's Campaign. So, again, we don't want to overplay the fact that there was dissension between the two groups. Right. Right. There seems to be much more solidarity in folks realizing that they were fighting a common enemy.

[00:25:37] So, Adam, I don't know if you also get this, but sometimes I'm asked the question, like, you know, what about reparations for indigenous folks? Yeah. Right. So what's your response when someone asks you that? My response is yes. Hell yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's almost like a rhetorical question. Like, yeah. But, yeah, but the way we usually hear it is, well, wait a minute about black reparations. Hold on, because, you know, that's not the only group entitled to reparations. So? True. Right. Okay. Agreed.

[00:26:06] So let's break down the legal case for indigenous reparations. Sure. Right. We're two lawyers here. So there are a few different bases under, you know, U.S. law that would presumably, you know, come into play here and actually support, you know, reparations. Under law. Under law. Yeah. Under existing law. First one is just straight, you know, damages, which are designed to compensate people for harms that they incurred. Right.

[00:26:36] So this is what we usually think of when we hear about a court case. Yeah. Someone was harmed in some way. They're compensated with damages. And, you know, maybe how you quantify the damages, there's some, you know, maybe some discrepancy about that. You bring an expert, so forth and so on. But for the mass scale of crimes that were committed, the genocide, the murder, the destruction of age-old cultures and civilizations, there's a price to pay for that. Pretty big one. Hell of a big one. Right.

[00:27:04] We don't have a number, but, you know, it's not de minimis. It seems like that number would have to be just about as big as any number we can even conceive of. Right. Just for starters. Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. The flip side of that is a notion of restitution, which relates to unjust enrichment that the perpetrator was able to obtain from that interaction. So it's basically the flip side of the same coin.

[00:27:31] So the focus in that instance is not on harm to the people that were burned. Yeah. It's basically on the gains that were wrongfully acquired by the perpetrator. Right. So you say flip side, but it is a completely different thing, right? It's a separate thing. True. True. And in law, you know, in a legal case, you could certainly go for both. Absolutely. Right. Right. So in this example here, right, let's just take a look at the present value of the stolen land itself.

[00:27:59] So in other words, what's the real estate value of the current United States land for the whole country? Right. Yeah. I mean, I guarantee that it's a number that there's no way we can even wrap our heads around. You're right. Yeah. It's $131 trillion. Oh, man. With a T. Yeah. Not millions, not billions. $131 trillion. Well, I'm trying to think of anything else that's even, you know, talked about in the same conversation with those kind of numbers. Well, add that to the tab. Yeah. The tab is running.

[00:28:29] Yeah. It continues to run. So we talked about damages, talked about restitution, you know, just the actual treaties themselves, right? Which, again, the Supreme Law of the Land, just a small piece of the massive land theft. So the more than 200 treaties, which are the Supreme Law of the Land, include massive liability and reparations owed to the many indigenous nations and tribes just for these violations alone and of themselves. Right.

[00:28:55] And so that's obviously a tiny portion of the landmass of the U.S., but it's a lot, right? Like, especially that Fort Laramie Treaty, 70 million acres just right there. Yeah. Yeah. All that. All that adds up. And that seems like, if you're talking about reparations, that's like some low-hanging fruit to start off with. It's like, you know, how can you argue against treaty violations? What's the argument? You know, what is the argument? Right. It's a supreme law. So nothing above that.

[00:29:20] You know, we can also look to arguments rooted in international law, that these were violations of sovereign governments. Right. And under, you know, international law, you know, those are crimes that were committed against them. Yeah. Yeah. So yet another part of international law that is there on the books, whatever, but, you know, we're just going to ignore that. Yeah. And what's the mechanism to enforce it? Exactly. Exactly. But, you know, it's definitely part of the case for reparations. Right.

[00:29:49] So, you know, simply put, there's no shortage of solid, legitimate, you know, legal doctrines to make the case for reparations. Sure. Right. So then what's getting in the way? Right. As always, it comes down to power, control, and will. Yeah. You know? Yeah. Who's controlling things? Who's controlling things and who's wanting to, you know, engage in this conversation and to make right what has been wrong? Yeah, exactly.

[00:30:17] It's what friend of the podcast, DeMario Solomon Simmons, told us, the amazing reparations lawyer in Tulsa, that, you know, it's not a question of, is there a valid case here? You know, that's like overkill. You know, it's like, yeah, there's a million good cases here. It's all about power. And it's all about making the powers that be respect the law, respect humanity. That's where our struggle begins. Yeah, absolutely.

[00:30:42] You know, and, you know, bottom line is that there's a gigantic tab for reparations for both indigenous Americans, Native Americans, and black Americans. That's right. It's not one, not either or, one, not, you know, one, but maybe not two, but it's both. Both. And it's so large. I mean, it boggles the mind. It's hard to get our heads around, which is part of the problem. But we haven't even tried. Right. We have to at least try. We have to put these concepts in mind and be talking about them, thinking about them. Be talking about it, be creative about it.

[00:31:12] And you can't thwart the process because it's challenging. One of the hardest parts here for indigenous reparations and black reparations is to acknowledge the immense claims that are just there. Yeah. Right. And I think especially with indigenous Americans, because, you know, everyone living in America today, right? Our entire country, our entire culture, our lives are built on this mountain of genocide and theft and just these mass crimes. Yeah. Right. Yeah.

[00:31:41] And so we've talked about it in the context of black reparations. But, yeah, I mean, I think a lot of people are almost scared to talk about native reparations because it's where does it begin? Where does it end? And it's kind of a scary thought. Well, it is. Like we're all living on stolen land. Completely. The enormity of it, the vastness of it, I think just has your, yeah, people just saying, you know what? I don't even want to look there. I don't even want to go there. Yeah. Yeah.

[00:32:08] You know, for me, the best way to grapple with this is really just to talk about it and just get in the conversation. You know, we're all trying to be a little bit better versed in our history and these perspectives and just add to our understanding of the world. We should want to know how the world works, you know? Well, it's interesting. You said that we're all trying to be, you know, better versed in history, but there's a whole bunch of folks that are actually actively trying to disguise history. Absolutely. And prevent us from digging into it. Yeah.

[00:32:34] So this kind of leads us to the question, you know, what can be done about these massive injustices, you know, given that our government is all powerful and it actively attacks all movements for change, right? And also, you know, what are the latest developments in the movement for justice for indigenous Americans? So in part two of this series, we have an amazing guest to help us address these big questions. Her name is Janine Yazzie. Yes. And she's a leading voice in today's indigenous movements for justice.

[00:33:01] She's at the cutting edge of the struggle from the land back movement to the international movements of indigenous peoples all around the world. So we will go deep with Janine about all these issues and also the critical importance of solidarity between Native and black Americans. Absolutely. So until next time, folks, stay tuned. Folks, thanks for listening. If you like what we're doing, please tell your friends and family about the show and give us a review on Apple Podcasts. And if you can, please contribute on our sub-staff.

[00:33:30] Help us bring more great stories to you. Our theme music is by the artists Logi and Swarby. Artwork by Jackie Rudinsky. See you guys next time. It's hard to be broke. Let's open up shop. Or get the money. Grab it all and we out.